In partnership with Scientific American
Why History Urges Caution on Immunity Testing
In the rush to re-open the world’s economies, an idea has been taking shape: field a workforce of survivors who can be shown to have Covid-19 antibodies. But history urges caution.
One hurdle is scientific. The gold standard, testing that detects HIV antibodies, took years to develop, so it should come as no surprise that creating a specific and sensitive test for the new coronavirus has proved tricky. Moreover, it remains unclear whether the presence of antibodies confers lasting immunity to Covid-19.
A second obstacle is social: What would creating a privileged workforce do to a society that is already stratified? While companies are rushing out digital certification apps they promise can act as passports for a new workforce, science historians and ethicists are raising an alarm. They say a great deal can be learned from looking back in history to times when desperate people would “buy the pox,” and survival after yellow fever became more than the ultimate resume enhancement.
More Like This
Xenophobia in the Age of COVID-19
Scapegoating immigrant groups in times of disease outbreak has a long history.
Coronavirus: Lessons From Past Epidemics
Dr. Larry Brilliant, who helped eradicate smallpox, says past epidemics can teach us to fight coronavirus.
Coronavirus Quarantine: Are There Lessons From A Nurse Who Challenged One For Ebola?
Coronavirus has public health officials scrambling to put quarantines into effect. The 2014 Ebola outbreak may have some lessons.
AIDS: From Ryan White to Today's Silent Epidemic
While H.I.V. rates have fallen in many places, the AIDS crisis remains in some of the U.S.